I think I posted something similar to this previously. I love lists- I can't get enough of them. My favorite is Best Rock Guitarist. You see there are so many opinions on this that is positively scary. People vote for their sentimental favorite and base things on one criterium, rather than looking at other factors. Technical skill is certainly one criteria, but it is not the be all, end all. If that were true, then the top 5 would not have any Rock guitarists, it would be made up exclusively of classical and jazz artists. Despite neo-classical metal's attempt to co-opt classic music, it is schlocky compared to artistry of Andres Segovia and Wes Montgomery. However, when people point this out, they say that they are boring. Exactly my point. While I do not find the aforementioned boring, they are certainly no showmen. Being the guitarist in a rock band is to be a showman the foundation of the song.
What is really astounding is that you are not really seeing any amazing players develop in the Indie movement. I am surprised. Most indie music I listen to is guitar-based. Yes, I know that most indie bands eschew the solo, but as Townshend demonstrated you have brilliant guitar that compliments a song, not overshadowing it. Perhaps it is an ego thing. If you are, in fact, a virtuoso on guitar, you want to be noticed. The indie scene is not that place. I guess that is why talented musicians like Petrucci go on to form a progressive metal band. I think it is a shame. Look at The Smiths, one of the first indie-type bands. Without Johnny Marr (now, thankfully of Modest Mouse), they would have been, well, Morrissey. This is a call to the indie community to start to find better musicians. Perhaps it is the punk DIY aesthetic, but I think that we only have to look at history to see that you can have both. The Clash, after a few years, become very good musicians and demonstrated a keen eye for musical bending genres. Imagine if Sufjan Stevens (not my favorite, but I appreciate him) could play acoustic guitar as well as say, Joni Mitchell.
So here is my criterium:
1. Songwriting Skills- it is one thing to be technically proficient, it takes a different and special talent to compose the music.
2. Riff ability- This is distinguished from 1 above in that there are some guitarists that may not write the entire song, but can lay down an infectious riff that become legendary.
3. Inventiveness- The ability to push the boundaries, to cross many musical styles, to challenge their core audience.
4. Concert ability- sure anyone can put down a good performance, a good ax man should be able to hypnotize an audience
5. Technical ability- through countless hours of practice, come perfection. However, as alluded to, with perfection comes a certain sterility (i.e. Yngve Malmsteen).
So here are my top 10:
1. Jimi Hendrix- I had always thought he was amazing, but when listening to his Blues CD, I was quickly reminded of where he started from. He set the standard for showmanship that has seldom been duplicated since. Riff ability is extraordinary. Inventiveness in the studio was unmatched during the time. He was looping and back-masking his guitar long before anyone else in the mainstream was even aware of it.
2. Eric Clapton- Listen to his early blues-based performances and you can feel his deep appreciation of the blues masters. He channeled them. Then, turning on a dime, he, along with Hendrix, quickly invented early metal with Cream. Then doing another hard turn, he moved into the beautiful Derek and the Dominos and showed true class by appreciating a fellow genius on guitar, Duane Allman.
3. Jimmy Page- Yes, Page can play sloppy at times, but he is probably the best song-writing guitarist in history. His depth of musical styles is unmatched. From hard rock, to folk, to Indian to old fashioned blues, Page was a chameleon. His solos are stuff of legends. Are they simple? I don't know frankly as I don't play the guitar, however, that is not the judge of a good guitarist, it is the impression it makes. Page has more lasting solos than almost any other guitarist.
4. David Gilmour of Pink Floyd- Years went by when he was an underrated guitarist, it seems that in hindsight his brilliance is finally be appreciated. His tone is hauntingly beautiful. He was very inventive and not a show-off. He textured his guitar to suit the rich music that they were making. He is amazing songwriter (although not as good as Roger Waters to be sure) and is very precise.
5. Duane Allman- Listen to one of his last performances at the Filmore shortly before he died and you will be in guitar bliss. Rock blues perfected. Enough said.
6. Steve Vai- although this is not my favorite type of music (shredding) he has shown that he has the technical brilliance of all the previous 5 rolled into one. He has a mastery of neo-classical rock as well as blues. He is low on the memorable riffs, songwriting and inventiveness.
7. Keith Richards- although he is certainly, by no means, the greatest technical guitarist, Richards is unparalleled at laying down memorable licks. His sound is utterly distinctive and his longevity is telling.
8. Chuck Berry- I absolutely love Berry. He was my first musical love when my dad used to play him for me when I was 3-4. He single handily introduced the guitar as the foundation of rock music. Prior to that it was a mere accompaniment.
9 Eddie Van Halen- In years of reading about guitarists, I know that much of his talent is based on a relatively simple technique called tapping. In other words, proficient guitarists will often say that his playing is really not that difficult. I do not care. I am not a metal fan by any means (and I am not sure that I would put Van Helen as metal per se, they were too poppy for that), but you have to admit that EVH is probably the third most influential guitarist behind Hendrix and Page. In the 80's he was the automatic answer of who was the best guitarist.
10. Pete Townshend- He is one of the most underrated guitarists out there. His complexity comes across even to non-guitar players. He is amazing songwriter and obviously pushed many creative elements (Tommy, Quadraphenia, etc.) His riff ability is up there with the best of them. He and Hendrix invented the rock guitarist showmanship and The Who has long been considered one of the best concert bands in history. I had my doubts as I saw them in 1989, the 20th anniversary of Tommy and I was not impressed, but I saw them in a domed area with horrible acoustics and even worse seats. Since then, I heard Live at Leeds and I defy anyone to claim that he is not up there with the best. Only Duane is better live.
Honorable mentions:
1. John Frusciante of RHCP- one note, you know its him. Introspective playing only rivaled by Gilmour.
CURRENTLY LISTENING TO:
Who's Joe from the album "Waiting For The Sirens' Call" by New Order
[posted with ecto]
Technorati Tags: Angus Young, Chuck Berry, David Gilmour, DC, Duane Allman, Eric Clapton, Jimi Hendrix, Jimmy Page, John Frusciante, Johnny Marr, Joni Mitchell, Ritchie Blackmore, Steve Vai